Skip to content

The Politics of Feigned Impartiality: A Critical Response to “The Politics of Historical Knowledge”

Andrew Logie


Pages 117 - 150

DOI https://doi.org/10.13173/jasiahist.53.1.0117a




1 An Chŏngjun 안정준. “Onŭl nal ŭi Nangnanggun yŏngu” 오늘날의 낙랑군 연구 [Present-day research on the Lelang Commandery], Yŏksa-bip'yŏng 역사비평 114 (2016), 262–284.

2 An Hosang 安浩相. Paedal ŭi chonggyo wa ch'ŏrhak kwa yŏksa 배달의 종교와 철학과 역사 [Religion, philosophy and history of Paedal]. Seoul: Ŏmungak 어문각, 1964.

3 An Hosang 安浩相. Paedal tong'i nŭn tong'i kyŏre wa tong'a munhwa ŭi palsangji 배달·동이는동이겨레와 동아문화의 발상지 [Paedal and Dongyi were the place of origin of the Dongyi people]. Seoul: Paeg'ak munhwasa 백악문화사, 1979.

4 An Kyŏngjŏn 안경전 (tr. and annot.). Hwandan kogi (pogŭp p'an) 桓檀古記 (보급판) [Old records of the Hwan and Tan states (popular distribution edition)]. Daejeon-si: Sangsaeng 상생출판, 2012.

5 Baek Jong-oh. “North Korean Research on Koguryŏ Remains: Status and Results”, in Byington (ed.) 2016(2).

6 Breuker, Remco E. Establishing a Pluralist Society in Medieval Korea, 918–1170: History, Ideology, and Identity in the Koryo Dynasty. Leiden; Boston: Brill, 2010.

7 Byington, Mark E. “A Matter of Territorial Security: China's historiographical treatment of Koguryŏ in the Twentieth Century”, Nationalism and History Textbooks in Asia and Europe: Diverse Views on Conflicts Surrounding History. Seoul: The Center for Information on Korean Culture, Academy of Korean Studies, 2005.

8 Byington, Mark E. (ed.). The Samhan Period in Korean History. Cambridge (MA): Early Korea Project, Korea Institute, Harvard University, 2009.

9 Byington, Mark E. (ed.). The Han Commanderies in Early Korean History. Cambridge (MA): Early Korea Project, Korea Institute, Harvard University, 2013.

10 Byington, Mark E. The Ancient State of Puyŏ in Northeast Asia: Archaeology and Historical Memory. Cambridge, Massachusetts: Published by the Harvard University Asia Center, 2016 (1).

11 Byington, Mark E. (ed.). The History and Archaeology of the Koguryŏ Kingdom. Cambridge (MA): Early Korea Project, Korea Institute, Harvard University, 2016 (2).

12 Ch'oe Tong 崔棟. Chosŏn sanggo minjok sa 朝鮮上古民族史 (The Ancient History of Korean Peoples by Choy Dong M.D.). Seoul: Tongguk munhwasa 東國文化社, 1966.

13 Chŏlmŭn Yŏksa Hakcha Moim 젊은역사학자모임 [Young historians' collective]. Hanguk kodaesa wa saibiyŏksahak 한국 고대사와 사이비역사학 [Early Korean history and pseudo historiography]. Goyang-si: Yŏksa pip'yŏngsa 역사비평사, 2017.

14 Chŏn Mun-gyu. Siljŭng paedalguksa 실증 배달국사 1 [Actual proof for the history of the Paedal state]. Seoul: Bungnaep 북랩, 2017.

15 Chŏng In-bo 정인보. Chosŏnsa yŏngu (sang) 朝鮮史研究 (上) [Research on Korean history]. Seoul: Uriyŏksa yŏngu chaedan 우리역사연구재단, 2012.

16 Chŏng, T'ei 테이 정 (Tay Jeong). “‘Saibi sahak’ pip'an ŭl pip'anhanda” “사이비 사학” 비판을 바판한다. Yŏksa pip'yŏng 역사비평. 124 (2018), 438–469.

17 Guo Da-shun. “Hongshan and Related Cultures”, in: Nelson 1995, 21–64.

18 Im Sŭngguk 임승국 (tr. and annot.). Handan kogi 한단고기 [Old records of Han and Tan]. Seoul: Chŏsin segyesa 정신세계사, 1986.

19 Jeong, Tay [Chŏng, T'ei]. “The Politics of Historical Knowledge: The Debate on the Historical Geography of Old Chosŏn and Lelang Commandery”, Journal of Asian History 52.1 (2018), 43–82.

20 Jiang Weigong 姜維公. “Liaoshi dilizhi Dongjing Liaoyangfu tiao jishi miuwu tanyuan” 《遼史·地理志》東京遼陽府條記事誤謬探源, Zhongguo bianjiang shidi yanjiu 中国边疆史地研究, (2011.2), 119–129.

21 Jin Xudong. “The Discovery and Study of Koguryŏ Remains in Jilin Province”, in Byington (ed.) 2016(2).

22 Jung In-seung. “The Material Culture of Lelang Commandery”, in Byington (ed.) 2013, 157–164.

23 Jung Inseung 정인성. “Kogohak ŭro pon wimanchosŏn wanggŏmsŏng” 고고학으로 본위만조선 왕검성 [Wiman Chosŏn's Wanggŏm-sŏng examined through archaeology], Hanguk kogohak hakpo 韓國考古學學報 106 (2018.3), 104–137.

24 Kim Ch'ŏr-ung 김철웅. “Yŏnhaengnok e nat'anan koguryŏ insik” 燕行錄에 나타난 고구려인식 [Understanding of Koguryŏ as seen in Yŏnhaegnok travel accounts to the Qing capital], in: Pok 2017, 39–60.

25 Kim Hyŏngu 김현구. Singmin sahak ŭi k'arŭt'el 식민사학의 카르텔 [Colonial historiography cartel]. Seoul: Isang midiŏ 이상미디어, 2017.

26 Kim Kyohŏn 金敎獻. Sindanmin sa 神檀民史, kwŏn 卷 1–2 [History of the divine Tan people. Books 1–2]. Handwritten mimeograph, 1904.

27 Kim Kyohŏn 金敎獻.: Sindan silgi 神檀實記, [Veritable records of divine Tan]. Kyŏngsŏng 京城: Taejonggyo ponsa 大倧敎本司], 1914.

28 Lieberman, Victor. Strange Parallels: Southeast Asia in Global Context, c. 800–1830. New York: Cambridge University, 2003.

29 Loewe, Michael (ed.). Early Chinese Texts: A Bibliographical Guide. New Haven: The Society for the Study of Early China, 1993.

30 Logie, Andrew. “Popular Korean Historiography in Northeast Asia: A critical survey from the 13th century until the present, pertaining to Early Korea”. PhD diss., Helsinki University, 2016.

31 Logie, Andrew. “The Tide Turns? Part I”, koreanology.wordpress.com/2018/03/17/the-tide-turns-2017-counter-critiques-of-pseudo-historiography-of-early-korea/ (last access 2018, Sept. 28) [Logie 2018 (1)].

32 Logie, Andrew. “The Tide Turns? Part II”, koreanology.wordpress.com/2018/03/19/the-tide-turns-part-2/ (last access 2018–09–28) [Logie 2018 (2)].

33 Logie, Andrew. “The Tide Turns? Part III”, koreanology.wordpress.com/2018/03/29/the-tide-turns-part-3/ (last access 2018–09–28) [Logie 2018 (3)].

34 Logie, Andrew. “The Tide Turns? Part IV”, koreanology.wordpress.com/2018/03/31/the-tide-turns-part-4/ (last access 2018–09–28) [Logie 2018 (4)].

35 Logie, Andrew. “The Tide Turns? Part V”, koreanology.wordpress.com/2018/04/01/the-tide-turns-part-5/ (last access 2018–09–28) [Logie 2018 (5)].

36 Mun Chŏng-ch'ang 文定昌. Hanguk syumerŭ isŭra'el ŭi yŏksa 韓國~슈메르 이스라엘의 歷史 [Korea and Sumer: Israel history]. Seoul: Paengmundang 柏文堂, 1979.

37 Nelson, Sarah M. (ed.). The Archaeology of Northeast China: Beyond the Great Wall. London and New York: Routledge, 1995.

38 Oh, Youngchan. “The Ruling Class of Lelang Commandery”, in Byington (ed.) 2013, 101–135.

39 Pae Usŏng 배우성. Chosŏn kwa chunghwa 조선과 중화 [Chosŏn and China]. P'ajusi 파주시: Tolbegae 돌베개.

40 Pai, Hyung Il. Constructing “Korean” Origins: A Critical Review of Archaeology, Historiography, and Racial Myth in Korean State-formation Theories. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2000.

41 Park, Saeyoung. “Me, Myself, and My Hegemony: The Work of Making the Chinese World Order a Reality”, Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies 77.1 (2017.6), 47–72.

42 Pok Kidae 복기대 (ed.). Koguryŏ ŭi p'yŏngyang kwa kŭ yŏun 고구려의 평양과 그 여운 [Koguryŏ's P'yŏngyang and its lingering influence]. Seoul: Churyusŏng ch'ulp'ansa, 2017.

43 Ri Chirin 리지린. Kochosŏn yŏngu 고조선 연구 [Research on ancient Chosŏn]. P'yŏngyang: Kwahak'wŏn ch'ulp'ansa 과학원 출판사, 1963.

44 Ri Chirin 리지린. Ri chirin ŭi kochosŏn yŏngu 리지린의 고조선 연구 —대륙고조선을 찾아서 [Ri Chirin's Research on Old Chosŏn: in search of continental Old Chosŏn]. Seoul: P'ip'ŭllain 피플라인, 2018 [1963].

45 Ryŏksa P'yŏnjipsil 력사 편집실. [History compilation room]. Tangun kwa kojosŏn e kwanhan yŏngu nonmunjip 단군과 고조선에 관한 연구 논문집 [Collected research papers relating to Tangun and ancient Chosŏn]. P'yŏngyang: Sahoe kwahak ch'ulp'ansa 사회과학출판사, 1994.

46 Schmid, Andre. “Rediscovering Manchuria: Sin Ch'aeho and the Politics of Territorial History in Korea”, Journal of Asian Studies 56.1 (1997), 26–47.

47 Schmid, Andre. Korea between Empires, 1895–1919. New York: Columbia University Press, 2002.

48 Sim Chaehun 심재훈. “Isip segi hanguk sanggosa yŏngu e taehan pansŏng: Hyun Il Pai, Constructing “Korean” Origins” 20 세기 한국 상고사 연구에 대한 반성 [Reflecting on 20th-century Korean research on early history] Yŏksa hakpo 歷史學報 172 (2001), 367–376.

49 Sim Chaehun 심재훈. “Kumiŭi Han'guk sanggosa yŏn'guwa habŏdŭ ‘Kodae-Han'guk p’ŭrojekt'ŭ'” 구미의 한국 상고사 연구와 하버드 “고대한국 프로젝트” [North American research on early Korea and the Harvard “Early Korea Project”] Sahakchi 사학지 52 (2016), 83–107.

50 Sin Ch'ae-ho, Tanjae 단재 신채호. Chosŏn sanggosa 조선상고사 [History of ancient Korea]. Seoul: Pibong ch'ulp'ansa 비봉출판사, 2006.

51 Sin Ch'ae-ho, Tanjae 단재 신채호. Chosŏn sanggo munhwasa 조선상고 문화사 [Cultural history of ancient Korea]. Seoul: Pibong ch'ulp'ansa 비봉출판사, 2007.

52 Sin Yongha 신용하. Kochosŏn munmyŏng ŭi sahoesa 고조선문명의 사회사 [A social history of Old Chosŏn civilization]. Pajusi: Chisik sanŏpsa 지식산업사, 2018.

53 Song Ho Jung. “Old Chosŏn – Its History and Archaeology”, in Byington (ed.) 2013, 49–80.

54 Tikhonov, Vladimir. “The Rise and Fall of the New Right Movement and the Historical Wars in 2000s South Korea”, European Journal of Korean Studies (2019) 18.2.

55 Wang, Sixiang. “Co-constructing Empire in Early Chosŏn Korea: Knowledge Production and the Culture of Diplomacy, 1392–1592”. PhD diss., Columbia University, 2015.

56 Wilkinson, Endymion. Chinese History: A New Manual. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2013.

57 Yang Sŏngmin 양성민. Mujigae minjŏk kojosŏn yŏksa ŭi pimil 무제개민족 고조선 역사의비밀 [The rainbow ethnic nation: the secret of Old Chosŏn's history]. Bucheon: Chiech'it'ek'ŭ 지에치테크, 2018.

58 Yi Mun-yŏng 이문영. “Hwandan kogi ŭi sŏngnip paegyŏng kwa kwŏn” 『환단고기』의 성립배경과 기원 [The background and origins to Hwandan kogi's creation], Yŏksa-bip'yŏng 역사비평 118 (2017), 40–73.

59 Yi Tŏgil 이덕일 and Kim Pyŏnggi 김병기. Kojosŏn ŭn taeryuk ŭi chibaeja yŏtta 고조선은대륙의 지배자였다 [Old Chosŏn were rulers of the continent]. Uri yŏksa parojapki 우리역사 바로잡기 [Correcting our history], 1: Goyang-si: Wisdom House 위즈덤하우스, 2006.

60 Yi Tŏgil 이덕일 and Kim Pyŏnggi 김병기. Koguryŏ nŭn ch'ŏnja ŭi cheguk iŏtta 고구려는 천자의 제국이었다 [Koguryŏ was the empire of the son of heaven]. Uri yŏksa parojapki, 2. Goyang-si: Wisdom House, 2007.

61 Yi Tŏgil 이덕일 and Kim Pyŏnggi 김병기. Hanguksa, kŭdŭl i sumgin chinsil 한국사, 그들이 숨긴 진실 [Korean history, the truth they hid]. Goyang-si: Wisdom House, 2009.

62 Yi Tŏgil 이덕일 and Kim Pyŏnggi 김병기. Uri an ûi singminsagwan: haebang toeji mothan yŏksa, kǔdǔr ǔn ŏttŏk'e uri rǔl chibae haenunga 우리 안의 식민사관: 해방되지 못한 역사, 그들은 어떻게 우리를 지배했는가 [The colonial view of history within us: unliberated history, how have they controlled us?]. Seoul: Man'gwŏndang 만권당, 2014.

63 Yi Tŏgil 이덕일 and Kim Pyŏnggi 김병기. Maeguk ui yŏksahak, ŏdi kkaji wanna 매국의 역사학, 어디까지 왔나 [Treasonous historiography, how far has it come?]. Seoul: Man'gwŏndang, 2015.

64 Yun Hant'aek 윤한택 and Pok Kidae 복기대 (ed.). Amnok kwa koryŏ ǔi pukkye 압록(鴨淥)과 고려의 북계 [The Amnok and Koryŏ's northern border]. Seoul: Churyusŏng ch'ulp'ansa, 2017.

65 Yun Naehyŏn 윤내현, Pak Sŏnhŭi 박선희, and Ha Munsik 하문식. Kojosŏn ŭi kangyŏk ŭl palk'inda 고조선의 강역을 밝힌다 [Demonstrating the territory of Old Chosŏn]. Paju-si: Chisik sanŏpsa, 2006.

66 Yun Naehyŏn 윤냐현. Kojosŏn yŏngu (sang, ha) 고조선 연구 (상, 하) [Research on Old Chosŏn (parts 1 and 2)]. Seoul: Man'gwŏndang, 2015, 2016.

67 Yun Naehyŏn 윤냐현. Hanguk kodaesa sillon 한국 고대사 신론 [A new theory of early Korean history]. Seoul: Man'gwŏndang, 2017 [1986].

Share


Export Citation